In today's fast-paced and ever-evolving job market, informal interviews have become an increasingly popular way for employers to assess potential candidates. These less structured and more casual conversations offer a unique opportunity for both parties to get to know each other on a deeper level, beyond the confines of a formal interview setting. If you're new to the concept of informal interviews or looking to refine your skills, this comprehensive guide will walk you through the process from start to finish. So grab a cup of coffee, put on your favorite comfy clothes, and let's dive in!

Understanding the Informal Interview

Defining the Informal Interview

At its core, an informal interview is an unstructured conversation between an employer and a potential candidate. Unlike formal interviews, which typically follow a set list of questions and a rigid format, informal interviews are more relaxed and open-ended. They allow employers to gauge a candidate's personality, cultural fit, and overall communication style, while giving candidates the opportunity to learn more about the company and the role they are applying for.

Importance of Informal Interviews

Informal interviews serve as a valuable tool in the hiring process. They help employers assess a candidate's soft skills, such as their ability to think on their feet, their communication style, and their interpersonal skills. These interviews also provide candidates with a chance to showcase their personality and demonstrate how they would fit into the company's culture. Additionally, informal interviews allow both parties to ask questions and gather more information that may not have been covered in a formal interview, creating a more holistic view of the candidate and the role.

Differences between Formal and Informal Interviews

While formal interviews are structured and often follow a specific format, informal interviews are much more relaxed and conversational. In formal interviews, candidates are usually asked a series of predetermined questions, while in informal interviews, the conversation flows more naturally and can cover a wide range of topics. Formal interviews typically take place in a dedicated office space, while informal interviews may occur in a more casual setting, such as a coffee shop or over a video call.

During an informal interview, employers have the opportunity to observe a candidate's body language and non-verbal cues, which can provide valuable insights into their level of comfort and confidence. For example, a candidate who maintains eye contact and nods attentively during the conversation may convey a high level of engagement and interest. On the other hand, a candidate who fidgets or avoids eye contact may indicate nervousness or lack of confidence.

Informal interviews also allow employers to assess a candidate's ability to adapt and think on their feet. By engaging in a more spontaneous and unstructured conversation, employers can observe how well a candidate responds to unexpected questions or situations. This can provide valuable insights into their problem-solving skills and their ability to handle ambiguity, which are often crucial in today's fast-paced and dynamic work environments.

Preparing for an Informal Interview

Setting the Right Environment

Before diving into an informal interview, it's essential to set the right environment. Choose a location that allows for comfortable and uninterrupted conversation. Ensure there are minimal distractions and find a space where both parties can feel at ease. Whether it's a cozy cafe or a quiet conference room, the environment should foster open and honest communication.

Consider the ambiance of the chosen location as well. A warm and welcoming atmosphere can help put both you and the interviewee at ease, encouraging a more relaxed and genuine conversation. Soft lighting, comfortable seating, and a pleasant decor can all contribute to creating a positive environment for the interview.

Planning the Interview Questions

While informal interviews are less structured, it's still crucial to have a general plan in mind. Prepare a list of questions that will help you learn more about the candidate and their qualifications. These questions can cover topics such as their previous experience, their motivations, and their goals. However, keep in mind that the conversation should flow naturally, so be prepared to deviate from your planned questions if the conversation takes an interesting turn.

Consider incorporating situational or behavioral questions into your list. These types of questions can provide valuable insights into how the candidate approaches challenges and interacts with others. By including a mix of different question types, you can gain a more comprehensive understanding of the interviewee's skills and suitability for the role.

Understanding the Interviewee's Background

Take the time to research the candidate before the interview to gain a better understanding of their background and experiences. This will allow you to tailor your questions and show genuine interest in their journey. By familiarizing yourself with their skills and accomplishments, you can make the conversation more personalized and meaningful.

Look beyond the candidate's resume and delve deeper into their online presence, such as their professional profiles or any published work. This additional research can provide valuable context and help you ask more insightful questions during the interview. Demonstrating a genuine interest in the interviewee's background can also help build rapport and establish a more meaningful connection during the conversation.

Conducting the Informal Interview

Starting the Conversation

When starting an informal interview, it's essential to create a comfortable and welcoming atmosphere. Begin the conversation with a warm greeting and a brief introduction of yourself. Put the candidate at ease by allowing them to share a little about themselves before diving into more specific questions. Remember, the goal is to create a relaxed and genuine rapport.

Furthermore, establishing a connection beyond the professional realm can help in building a stronger relationship with the candidate. You can initiate small talk about common interests or experiences to break the ice and foster a sense of camaraderie. This personal touch can make the interviewee feel valued and respected, leading to more open and insightful conversations.

Navigating the Interview Process

Unlike formal interviews that follow a predefined structure, informal interviews require flexibility. Let the conversation flow naturally, allowing the candidate to expand on their responses and share anecdotes or insights. Be an active listener, asking follow-up questions that delve deeper into their experiences and perspectives. Remember, the goal is to get to know the candidate on a personal and professional level.

Moreover, incorporating situational or hypothetical scenarios can provide valuable insights into how the candidate thinks and problem-solves in real-time. By presenting these scenarios, you can observe their decision-making process and assess their critical thinking skills. This approach adds a dynamic element to the interview, making it more engaging and informative for both parties involved.

Keeping the Interview on Track

While it's important to have a relaxed atmosphere, it's equally essential to keep the interview on track. Gently guide the conversation back to the key points and topics you want to cover. This will ensure that you gather the necessary information while still maintaining the informal and conversational tone. Balance is key!

Additionally, summarizing key points or insights discussed throughout the interview can help in reinforcing important takeaways for both you and the candidate. By recapping significant details, you can ensure clarity and alignment on crucial aspects, fostering a more productive discussion. This reflective practice also demonstrates your attentiveness and commitment to understanding the candidate's background and qualifications thoroughly.

After the Informal Interview

Evaluating the Information Gathered

After the interview, take some time to evaluate the information you gathered. Reflect on the candidate's responses, their interpersonal skills, and the overall impression they made. Consider how well they align with the company culture and the requirements of the role. Remember, the goal is to find the best fit for both the company and the candidate.

As you review the information, pay attention to the subtle cues and non-verbal communication that may have influenced your impression of the candidate. Did their body language convey confidence and engagement? Did they maintain eye contact and actively listen? These details can provide valuable insights into their level of interest and their ability to connect with others.

Following Up with the Interviewee

Following up is an essential step in the informal interview process. Send a personalized email to express your gratitude for their time and to reiterate your interest in their candidacy. This demonstrates professionalism and keeps the lines of communication open. If appropriate, provide any next steps or additional information they may need.

Remember, the follow-up email is not just a formality; it is an opportunity to further gauge the candidate's interest and commitment. Pay attention to their response time and the level of detail they provide in their reply. This can give you valuable insights into their enthusiasm for the position and their communication skills.

Incorporating Feedback into Future Interviews

As you gain more experience with informal interviews, don't forget to incorporate feedback into future interviews. Identify areas where the conversation flowed smoothly, as well as areas where you could improve. By continually refining your approach, you can ensure that each informal interview becomes a valuable and effective part of your hiring process.

Consider seeking feedback from other team members who were present during the interview. Their perspectives can provide a well-rounded assessment of the candidate's fit within the team dynamics. Additionally, keep a record of the questions that yielded the most insightful responses, as well as any unexpected challenges that arose during the interview. This documentation will serve as a valuable resource for future reference.

So there you have it - the ultimate guide to conducting an informal interview. Armed with these insights and tips, you're well-equipped to navigate the world of informal interviews with confidence and finesse. Remember, don't be afraid to let your guard down, show your personality, and truly get to know the candidates. Happy interviewing!

Informal interviews offer a unique opportunity to delve beyond the surface-level qualifications and truly understand the candidate's potential. By carefully evaluating the information gathered, following up with the interviewee, and incorporating feedback into future interviews, you can ensure that your hiring process is thorough and effective. So go ahead, embrace the informal interview approach, and discover the hidden gems that may be the perfect fit for your team.

Ready to transform your team's culture and make work feel like play? At Candor, we're dedicated to helping you build a workplace where everyone feels like they belong—a place that feels like home. Embrace the power of authentic connections and shared responsibility in shaping your team's culture with our day-to-day exercises. Sign up for Free today and start creating a collaborative, authentic, and joyful work environment with Candor. Let's make culture your team's superpower!

Set up Shoutouts Mission on CandorSet up Shoutouts Mission on CandorSet up your profile on CandorSet up your profile on CandorSet up Work Checkins Mission on CandorSet up Work Checkins Mission on CandorSet up Personal Checkins Mission on CandorSet up Personal Checkins Mission on CandorSet up Polls Mission on CandorSet up Polls Mission on CandorSet up Feedback Mission on CandorSet up Feedback Mission on CandorSet up Feedback Mission on CandorSet up Feedback Mission on Candor

Connect and engage with your teammates

Candor makes it easy to connect and have fun with your teammates, even while you’re remote. Use Candor to do feedback, shoutouts, check-ins, and more, all in one place.

know your work
Connect with your teammates using shoutouts, check-ins, feedback and more.
Start using Candor for free
Sign up with Google
Already have an account? Login